
I remember my first leadership role like it was yesterday. After years of being a successful manager, I thought the transition would be natural. Spoiler alert: it wasn't quite that simple.
Today, as I coach new leaders through this exact transition, I see the same challenges arise time and time again. Perhaps you're facing them too?
The Manager-Leader Gap
Let's address the elephant in the room: management and leadership are different beasts. As one of my recent clients put it: "I was great at getting things done. But suddenly I needed to be great at getting things done through others – and that's a whole different skill set."
Here's what nobody tells you about this transition:
The Uncomfortable Truths
- Your Previous Strengths Might Not Serve You
Those exceptional organisational and technical skills that made you a stellar manager? They're still valuable, but they're no longer your primary toolkit. Leadership requires a different set of muscles. - The Metrics Have Changed
Success isn't just about hitting targets anymore. It's about:
• Developing others
• Creating a vision
• Building a culture
• Enabling innovation
• Fostering engagement - You'll Feel Like a Beginner Again (And That's OK)
My story: Imposter Syndrome dialled up to 11!
That first senior leadership role was one of the most challenging things I've ever done, and I've had twins! I felt like a massive imposter and spent all my time feeling like I was 'faking it til I made it'. And guess what? I never made it! My leadership approach was different to my peers and I really struggled to find my feet because I would second guess all of my decisions. Hello Imposter Syndrome 🖐 and self-doubt. The thing is, I was actually really good at my job, but all the pressure I put on myself to be 'perfect' meant I struggled to see it. So what advice can I share to help you through this tricky challenge?
The Critical Shifts
Here are the key shifts I needed to go through:
From Doing to Enabling:
• Manager: Completes tasks efficiently
• Leader: Creates environments where others can excel
From Knowing to Learning:
• Manager: Provides answers
• Leader: Asks powerful questions
From Control to Trust:
• Manager: Directs work
• Leader: Empowers others
From Problems to Possibilities:
• Manager: Solves immediate issues
• Leader: Envisions future opportunities
Practical Steps for Your Journey
- Embrace the Discomfort
Leadership growth happens outside your comfort zone. That uncertain feeling? It's a sign you're growing. - Find Your Leadership Voice
You don't need to mimic other leaders. Authentic leadership builds trust. Start by identifying your values and strengths and then lead from there. - Build Your Support Network
Find a mentor, join leadership groups, or work with a leadership coach. You don't have to figure this out alone.
A Personal Note
In my years of leadership coaching, I've noticed that those who succeed in this transition share one crucial trait: they're willing to be learners again. They understand that leadership is a journey, not a destination. They don't have all the answers and they know they don't need to.
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
• Trying to prove yourself through doing more
• Holding onto old habits that no longer serve you
• Neglecting to delegate effectively
• Avoiding difficult conversations
Moving Forward
Remember, this transition is a marathon, not a sprint. Give yourself permission to:
• Make mistakes
• Ask for help
• Learn continuously
• Celebrate small wins
Your Next Steps
- Identify your leadership strengths
- Reflect on which areas of leadership feel most challenging for you
- Consider what support you need in this transition
Want to explore this further? I'd love to hear about your experiences, let's schedule a discovery call to discuss how leadership coaching could support your transition.
Remember: Every great leader started exactly where you are now. The key is to keep moving forward, one step at a time.